When I first met you I admit,
I saw more than I let on
We talked about comic books
And had a lot of smiles
The innocence was what we needed
When I next saw you I admit,
I was more glad than I let on
I saw your band and I fed 'em potatoes
The innocence was beautiful
Come to find out we're both in the same situation
We were bored but still in love,
What to do?
When I next saw you I admit,
I was sorely glad you pulled me closer
It was midnight on a hill overlooking your town
Those kisses we had were what we needed
When I next see you I admit,
I'm scared as hell for what might happen
'Cause we both know I'm in love with another girl,
And if she'd have me back I'd come a-runnin'
Come to find out we're both in a strange situation
Our hearts were to big to fall out of love,
What to do?